Thread:RedstoneDemigod/@comment-28905095-20170214205516

Are we really going to add any item which might be smelted into the Smelted category? I know it is possible to smelt all Ores, but it doesn't make sense to smelt Redstone Ore to get Redstone. The same applies to Diamond Ore, Coal Ore, which I've never heard of anyone actually Smelting.

The current text of the category is " Blocks and items that have gone through the process of smelting. " And in 99.99% of cases, Redstone, Diamond & Coal, have not gone through the process of smelting.

To me, it is nitpicking (or badge farming) to add stuff like the mentioned examples into the Smelted category. Is this what we really want? 